EOYC 2013 Community Contest Rules, Info & General Discussion

I will listen and judge all sets this weekend !
 
soniakdg said:
Another ratings from me :)

(tracklist/technique/sound quality/overall from 1 to 10)

Yoda:
tr: 8
tech: 7,5
qu: 7,5
ov: 7,5

MimaMix:
tr: 7,5
tech: 9
qu: 8,5
ov: 8,5

Distant Moon:
tr: 7,5
tech: 8
qu: 8
ov: 8

Cosmic Man:
tr: 9
tech: 9,5
qu: 9
ov: 9

451B:
tr: 7
tech: 9,5
qu: 8,5
ov: 8

Mr Roys:
tr: 7,5
tech: 9,5
qu: 9
ov: 9

DJ Chanfle:
tr: 8,5
tech: 9
qu: 9
ov: 9

Pkomar:
tr: 7
tech: 8,5
qu: 8
ov: 8

Tomexi:
tr: 8,5
tech: 9
qu: 9,5
ov: 9

Kimochi:
tr: 7,5
tech: 7,5
qu: 9,5
ov: 8
Click to expand...

Thanks for taking your time to listen my set. I hope you enjoy it!
 
pkomar said:
Back with more reviews...


pkomar - unrated (check it out yourself) :)
SoundBarrier 6.66/10
Cris7tian 7.33/10
Tom Amy 7.16/10
Lucas Bielecki: 8.5/10
Upliftboy: 6/10
Gab: 6.25/10
Denima: 6.5/10
Logic: 8.75/10
Jamie Peeters: 6.66/10
Rafal Sentiel; 6/10
Oliver Cattley: 6.75/10
Alex Wit: 6/10
Kimochi: 6/10
Tomexi: 7.5/10
DJ Chanfle: 5.5/10 (not the best set imo, nothing captured me and I didn't enjoy it too much) :(
Mr Ryos: 5.5/10 (there are some very good tracks, mixing is not bad either, but I hate the fact that it contains 17 tracks, I'm not a fan of sets like these, they lack 'flow' in my opinion)
Cosmin Man: 5/10 (I have mixed feelings about this set, there are some great tracks but there are also awful picks (of course for me) mixing is good, tracks mostly didn't suit me, lacked flow because there were styles that didn't really get along together) :(

Unfortunately none of these sets suited me. Mr Ryos picked great tracks, set lacked flow imo. Cosmin Man on the other hand didn't grab my attention at all with his selection. DJ Chanfle played a good set, just not for my ears. You should all check out these sets, though. My notes are based on my personal feeling of the set, so don't get bothered by them much unless you have taste similar to mine. Check out these sets yourself, these guys would appreciate it, I think. :)
Click to expand...

Thanks for listen my set. I´m sorry to hear that you don't like it, your critics are very important to me. Again thanks.
 
pkomar said:
Back with more reviews...


pkomar - unrated (check it out yourself) :)
SoundBarrier 6.66/10
Cris7tian 7.33/10
Tom Amy 7.16/10
Lucas Bielecki: 8.5/10
Upliftboy: 6/10
Gab: 6.25/10
Denima: 6.5/10
Logic: 8.75/10
Jamie Peeters: 6.66/10
Rafal Sentiel; 6/10
Oliver Cattley: 6.75/10
Alex Wit: 6/10
Kimochi: 6/10
Tomexi: 7.5/10
DJ Chanfle: 5.5/10 (not the best set imo, nothing captured me and I didn't enjoy it too much) :(
Mr Ryos: 5.5/10 (there are some very good tracks, mixing is not bad either, but I hate the fact that it contains 17 tracks, I'm not a fan of sets like these, they lack 'flow' in my opinion)
Cosmin Man: 5/10 (I have mixed feelings about this set, there are some great tracks but there are also awful picks (of course for me) mixing is good, tracks mostly didn't suit me, lacked flow because there were styles that didn't really get along together) :(

Unfortunately none of these sets suited me. Mr Ryos picked great tracks, set lacked flow imo. Cosmin Man on the other hand didn't grab my attention at all with his selection. DJ Chanfle played a good set, just not for my ears. You should all check out these sets, though. My notes are based on my personal feeling of the set, so don't get bothered by them much unless you have taste similar to mine. Check out these sets yourself, these guys would appreciate it, I think. :)
Click to expand...

Hey pkomar, thanks for listening to my set.
Indeed my set was mixed to keep the energy going, and forgo-ed smooth mixing in favor of thumping transitions, never pausing to enjoy the subtle chimes underneath each vibe :wink:
 
DJ Alex The Lion said:
I see, there's some people who want to hear my opinion about the set by DJ Chanfle..
Sooooym...

khm.
Tracks: 4.5 of 5
Mixing: 5 of 5
Flow: 3.5 of 5
Overall: 4.2 of 5

Mr. Ryos is burning up my stage :) Let's see if you could make it
Click to expand...

Thanks Alex for listen my set. I hope you like it!
 
Lucas said:
Yeah, I believe We should not vote for our own mixes.
Click to expand...

Not voting for your own mix (while voting for others) is like saying you don't want to win. Voting for yourself and no one else would seem a bit sleazy, though.
 
I'm going to use similar vote mechanism as DJ Alex The Lion
Would love to give you all 10/10 ... however than there is no point in voting ;) So will be honest...

Explained how I vote
Tracks:
the choice of tracks + genre used + selection made
Mixing:
More the technical side, how far that is still technical, how far can you hear it, how does it fit in with next track, so purely about transistions ... some mix without sync, but difficult to find out... hmm
Flow:
the order you selected, if it gets boring, if the flow continues well or if there is a break that doesn't fit in or bpm has too big difference, if you start flying you got trance

Here are the sets I listened to so far

---
Cris7ian
Tracks: 9/10
Mixing: 9/10
Flow: 8/10
Overall: 8.6/10
---
Tom Amy
Tracks: 9/10
Mixing: 9.5/10
Flow: 8.5/10
Overall: 9/10
Lovely set! Totally my style, getting vote
---
Lucas Bielecki
Tracks: 8/10
Mixing: 8.5/10
Flow: 8/10
Overall: 8.2/10
---
Gab
Later ...
---
UpliftBoy
Tracks: 9/10
Mixing: 9/10
Flow: 9/10
Overall: 9/10
Lovely set! Totally my style, getting vote
---
Denima
Tracks: 7.5/10
Mixing: 8.5/10
Flow: 8/10
Overall: 8/10
---
Jamie Peeters
Tracks: 6.5/10
Mixing: 9/10
Flow: 7/10
Overall: 7.5/10
---
Logic
Later...
---
Alex Wit
Tracks: 8/10
Mixing: 7/10
Flow: 7.5/10
Overall: 7.5/10
---
Rafal Sentiel
Tracks: 6/10
Mixing: 6/10
Flow: 6/10
Overall: 6/10
---
Oliver Cattley
Tracks: 7/10
Mixing: 8/10
Flow: 7.5/10
Overall: 7.5
---
Kimochi
Tracks: 8/10
Mixing: 7.5/10
Flow: 7.5/10
Overall: 7.7/10
---
Tomexi
Tracks: 4/10
Mixing: 7/10
Flow: 4/10
Overall: 5/10
---
pkomar
Tracks: 9.5/10
Mixing: 9.5/10
Flow: 9.5/10
Overall: 9.5/10
Awesome set! Totally my style, getting vote. :bow:
---

more to come!
 
Last edited:
:angry:
message from sendspace:↓
You cannot download more than one file at a time.

Please finish your current download first or upgrade to sendspace Pro™ to enable multiple, fast, top priority downloads.

wtf?! and the download speed is 80KB/s :thumbsdown: sure i will upgrade for pro just for download some sets :LMAO:

why some of you uploaded only to this shit server? DAN why you added this stupid server? zippyshare would be much better :(

come on peoples i'm waiting for another link of you who uploaded only to this sendspace anyway will not listen your sets so you have a zero chance to get a vote from me :wink:
 
CICA9THC said:
:angry:
message from sendspace:↓
You cannot download more than one file at a time.

Please finish your current download first or upgrade to sendspace Pro™ to enable multiple, fast, top priority downloads.

wtf?! and the download speed is 80KB/s :thumbsdown: sure i will upgrade for pro just for download some sets :LMAO:
Click to expand...

Worked for me yesterday, >400KB/s (though the first file was almost finished when I started downloading the second one). It's indeed down to 80 now.

Anyway, Mixcloud was even slower than that (50KB/s), and I had to hack around just to find a way to download the file.
 
Last edited:
soundbarrier said:
I'm going to use similar vote mechanism as DJ Alex The Lion
Would love to give you all 10/10 ... however than there is no point in voting ;) So will be honest...

Explained how I vote
Tracks:
the choice of tracks + genre used + selection made
Mixing:
More the technical side, how far that is still technical, how far can you hear it, how does it fit in with next track, so purely about transistions ... some mix without sync, but difficult to find out... hmm
Flow:
the order you selected, if it gets boring, if the flow continues well or if there is a break that doesn't fit in or bpm has too big difference, if you start flying you got trance

---
pkomar
Tracks: 9.5/10
Mixing: 9.5/10
Flow: 9.5/10
Overall: 9.5/10
Awesome set! Totally my style, getting vote. :bow:
---

more to come!
Click to expand...

Thanks for kind words! It's great to see, that you liked the set. :)
 
Last edited:
I'm so ashamed for my set .I don't have the time and had to do it in a hurry..my personal judge for my set:
tracks 6/5
mixing 2/5
flow 4/5
overall 3/5
and I started to listen the all sets
 
Vempele said:
Worked for me yesterday, >400KB/s (though the first file was almost finished when I started downloading the second one). It's indeed down to 80 now.

Anyway, Mixcloud was even slower than that (50KB/s), and I had to hack around just to find a way to download the file.
Click to expand...

i don't want to download the every set i will not listen every set from the first second to the last second i don't have so much time i just want to listen what tracks contains a set and on the mixcloud is possible listen online just like on the soundcloud and zippyshare...
 
soundbarrier said:
I'm going to use similar vote mechanism as DJ Alex The Lion
Would love to give you all 10/10 ... however than there is no point in voting ;) So will be honest...

Explained how I vote
Tracks:
the choice of tracks + genre used + selection made
Mixing:
More the technical side, how far that is still technical, how far can you hear it, how does it fit in with next track, so purely about transistions ... some mix without sync, but difficult to find out... hmm
Flow:
the order you selected, if it gets boring, if the flow continues well or if there is a break that doesn't fit in or bpm has too big difference, if you start flying you got trance

Here are the sets I listened to so far

---
Cris7ian
Tracks: 9/10
Mixing: 9/10
Flow: 8/10
Overall: 8.6/10
---
Tom Amy
Tracks: 9/10
Mixing: 9.5/10
Flow: 8.5/10
Overall: 9/10
Lovely set! Totally my style, getting vote
---
Lucas Bielecki
Tracks: 8/10
Mixing: 8.5/10
Flow: 8/10
Overall: 8.2/10
---
Gab
Later ...
---
UpliftBoy
Tracks: 9/10
Mixing: 9/10
Flow: 9/10
Overall: 9/10
Lovely set! Totally my style, getting vote
---
Denima
Tracks: 7.5/10
Mixing: 8.5/10
Flow: 8/10
Overall: 8/10
---
Jamie Peeters
Tracks: 6.5/10
Mixing: 9/10
Flow: 7/10
Overall: 7.5/10
---
Logic
Later...
---
Alex Wit
Tracks: 8/10
Mixing: 7/10
Flow: 7.5/10
Overall: 7.5/10
---
Rafal Sentiel
Tracks: 6/10
Mixing: 6/10
Flow: 6/10
Overall: 6/10
---
Oliver Cattley
Tracks: 7/10
Mixing: 8/10
Flow: 7.5/10
Overall: 7.5
---
Kimochi
Tracks: 8/10
Mixing: 7.5/10
Flow: 7.5/10
Overall: 7.7/10
---
Tomexi
Tracks: 4/10
Mixing: 7/10
Flow: 4/10
Overall: 5/10
---
pkomar
Tracks: 9.5/10
Mixing: 9.5/10
Flow: 9.5/10
Overall: 9.5/10
Awesome set! Totally my style, getting vote. :bow:
---

more to come!
Click to expand...

Why mine is later ? :D
 
Thanks for the great reviews of my mix guys, really, and congrats for your hard work listening the whole sets and delivering your votes. It seems that there are so many nice sets so the poll will be very interesting :super:
 
pkomar - unrated (check it out yourself) :)
SoundBarrier 6.66/10
Cris7tian 7.33/10
Tom Amy 7.16/10
Lucas Bielecki: 8.5/10
Upliftboy: 6/10
Gab: 6.25/10
Denima: 6.5/10
Logic: 8.75/10
Jamie Peeters: 6.66/10
Rafal Sentiel; 6/10
Oliver Cattley: 6.75/10
Alex Wit: 6/10
Kimochi: 6/10
Tomexi: 7.5/10
DJ Chanfle: 5.5/10
Mr Ryos: 5.5/10
Cosmin Man: 5/10
451b - 6/10 Definitely an interesting set. Good start, then it started to sound a bit similar to the rest of uplifting mixes, which is not a good thing in my opinion (I like unique sets, haha :) )

Distant Moon - 6/10 That set is really similar to the previous mix. Even both of them feature Bluman's mix of Tuvan near the end, haha :) I have same feelings about this mix as I have about 451b's set. ;)

soniak - 4/10 So many mashups played in this set (I HATE mashups :P ), also this mix wasn't too trancy. There were some good tracks (I Don't Deserve You) mixed with terrible tunes (Fiesta, mashup of Sanctuary). :(

MiMaMix - 6/10 yet another uplifting mix. Nothing wrong about it, nothing great about it. Solid set.

YoDA - 7.5/10. Tracklist is stellar, flow is great. I feel, that mixing is a bit lacking, though. Very good set overall. :)

Dan Carmelo - 4/10 Another set containing many mashups. That's not a good thing. Another rather uplifting set. That's yet another con. :(

Koroc - 5.5/10 Another set containing mashups. I don't get, why are you all loving them :) There are some very good tracks in this set (Sun In Your Eyes, Brilliant People), but these mashups are preventing me from enjoying the mix.

Christopher de Bart - 5.5/10. Not a bad track selection. It contains mashup, but at least there's only one :P That set is only 57mins long which is against contest rules. That's why I lowered the note a bit :P
 
After listening to most of these sets I'm pretty disappointed I didn't get a chance to submit my mix in the 0.02 second window that was open lol.

Good work and good luck to all involved, but originality was lacking.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Back
Top