cyalataque
Registered
- Joined
- Jun 28, 2010
- Messages
- 10,175
- Reaction score
- 6,529
Morning guys















Light mode so far

HAHALight mode so far![]()
Hello HelloI have also discovered something concrete regarding the tempo that justifies my caution. The same beat tracker yields:
A 112.35 — B 112.35 — C 143.55 — D 112.35 BPM.
However, the autocorrelation simultaneously reveals strong periodicities at—among others—approximately 89.1, 107.7, 129.2, 136.0, and 172.3 BPM. That is not a plausible series of distinct actual tempos for the same track; the algorithm is latching onto different rhythmic layers. My earlier figure of 140.03 must therefore be definitively discarded as a "measured BPM." We have not yet reliably resolved the beat.
That may be less spectacular than simply giving you "the answer is X," but for this experiment, I consider this a significant gain: we have now identified at least two instances where an automated figure looked convincing but failed to hold up under closer scrutiny.
I am now moving on to the level that could prove decisive for your original question: tonal function and the bass foundation—specifically E♭ versus G♭—across sections A through D. Then, before you reveal the identity, I want to present a firm, final conclusion: what has been proven, what is probable, and what the four recordings simply cannot prove.



CET 16:00 - 17:00
01. Lowi - Fortitude (Extended Mix) Reason II Rise Music
02. Richard Durand, RinatNevo - Goodbye My Love (Extended Mix) Magik Muzik
03. Transaphonic & Josie Sandfeld - Love Lights the Flame (Extended Mix)
04. SkyRaid UK, Nova7 - Root of Everything (Original Mix) One Forty Music
05. LightDJ - Under Open Skies (Extended Vocal Mix) /Vocals: Uncredited
@LightDJ can you put the exact Key of both versions: are both details at Beatport correct ?
Before the show I tried Ai (ChatGPT) to define them, yet it's a ' tough cookie ' still
![]()
Future Force Recordings
Profile: Independent UK trance label, founded by trio Hide & Seek (8), in conjunction with Jan Johnston.
Sublabels: Neon Drift
@LightDJiTunes Apple
![]()
Key Key Key
Using a harmonically separated CQT/chroma analysis, I get the following general results:
strongest candidate 2nd E♭ minor
A A♭ major B♭ minor 5th
B A♭ major B♭ minor lower
C E♭ major A♭ minor 3rd
D A♭ major ≈ B♭ minor — 5th
In itself, that is no proof that C is in E♭ major. It primarily demonstrates something else: the specific fragment or source material being analyzed significantly influences the ranking of the key profiles.
Now, consider your two candidates:
E♭ minor = E♭ F G♭ A♭ B♭ C♭ D♭
G♭ major = G♭ A♭ B♭ C♭ D♭ E♭ F
Exactly the same seven pitch classes. Consequently, a key detector that focuses mainly on which notes are present can hardly distinguish between the two in principle. The real proof must come from the question: does E♭ behave as i, or does G♭ behave as I?
That is why my next step isn't to run yet another key detector. I want to isolate the low-frequency/harmonic component from the four recordings and examine—phrase by phrase—where the bass fundamentals land, which chord functions recur, and where phrases resolve. That approach can effectively distinguish between E♭ minor and G♭ major.



20,763 members
20 years
I always look at Extended but i know beatport miss detection sometime , It should be Eb MinorCET 16:00 - 17:00
01. Lowi - Fortitude (Extended Mix) Reason II Rise Music
02. Richard Durand, RinatNevo - Goodbye My Love (Extended Mix) Magik Muzik
03. Transaphonic & Josie Sandfeld - Love Lights the Flame (Extended Mix)
04. SkyRaid UK, Nova7 - Root of Everything (Original Mix) One Forty Music
05. LightDJ - Under Open Skies (Extended Vocal Mix) /Vocals: Uncredited
@LightDJ can you put the exact Key of both versions: are both details at Beatport correct ?
Before the show I tried Ai (ChatGPT) to define them, yet it's a ' tough cookie ' still
![]()
Future Force Recordings
Profile: Independent UK trance label, founded by trio Hide & Seek (8), in conjunction with Jan Johnston.
Sublabels: Neon Drift
@LightDJiTunes Apple
![]()
