Tbh, none of the radio shows are consistently good
I havent heard Club Life enough to talk about its consistency, but the episodes Ive heard werent that great...but ASOT, only once every few episodes am I really satisfied...the same goes with GDJB and TATW
IMO these shows don't really appeal to the casual listnener rather than the DJ who needs to keep updated on the latest tracks...
I like some of the shows on AH much better, because they dont give airtime to crappy songs just for the sake of playing new songs...like Macarius's show, DarkMemoria's show, and Magik's show...
Mix CDs/albums are much better because its frankly a waste of money to put crap on cds...it wont sell...so you can be assured youre getting good songs...
Otherwise, most of the time I listen to my own tracks in my music library, cause I get only the best songs, or certain shows on Afterhours that I know will be good